The just-as-probable rule is a legal principle used in workers' compensation cases. It states that if it is equally possible for an injury to have occurred due to both work-related and non-work-related causes, the claim for compensation may be denied. Essentially, the burden of proof lies with the claimant to show that the injury was more likely caused by work-related activities than by other factors.
This rule is primarily applied in workers' compensation law, which deals with claims made by employees for injuries sustained while on the job. In legal practice, it helps determine whether a claimant has met the necessary burden of proof to receive compensation. Users may find relevant forms and templates on platforms like US Legal Forms, which can assist in filing claims or appeals related to workers' compensation.
Here are a couple of examples of abatement:
Example 1: A factory worker injures their back while lifting heavy boxes. If they claim the injury is work-related, but there is evidence they also have a history of back problems unrelated to work, the claim may be denied under the just-as-probable rule.
Example 2: An office employee develops carpal tunnel syndrome. If they can show that their work activities contributed significantly to the condition, they may succeed in their claim. However, if it is equally likely that the condition arose from non-work activities, the claim could be denied.
Examples of state differences (not exhaustive):
| State | Application of the Just-as-Probable Rule |
|---|---|
| Virginia | Explicitly applies the just-as-probable rule in workers' compensation claims. |
| California | Similar principles apply, but the burden of proof may differ slightly based on specific case law. |
| Texas | Uses a different standard for proving causation in workers' compensation cases. |
This is not a complete list. State laws vary, and users should consult local rules for specific guidance.
| Term | Definition | Difference |
|---|---|---|
| Burden of Proof | The obligation to prove one's assertion in a legal dispute. | The just-as-probable rule specifically addresses how the burden of proof is evaluated in workers' compensation cases. |
| Preponderance of Evidence | The standard of proof that requires more than 50% certainty to establish a claim. | The just-as-probable rule operates under this standard but focuses on the likelihood of work-related versus non-work-related causes. |
If you believe your injury may fall under the just-as-probable rule, consider the following steps:
Browse our library of 85,000+ state-specific legal templates.
If you cannot prove that your injury is more likely work-related, your claim may be denied.