US Legal Forms
Legal Resources
Questions & Answers
U.S. Constitution
Is it illegal for a school to make kids perform service learning, in the form of community service, as a

Is it illegal for a school to make kids perform service learning, in the form of community service, as a

Q: Is community service a graduation requirement?

In some schools, community service is indeed a graduation requirement. This can vary by district and state, so it's important for students to check their school's specific policies. Such requirements are often intended to promote civic engagement and social responsibility among students.

Q: What is forced volunteering called?

Forced volunteering is often referred to as 'involuntary servitude' or 'coerced volunteering.' While the intention behind community service requirements is typically to encourage civic engagement, when participation is mandatory, it can be viewed as a form of coercion rather than genuine volunteerism.

Q: Why shouldn't community service be mandatory in high school?

Making community service mandatory in high school can undermine its value, as students may participate out of obligation rather than a desire to help. This can lead to a lack of genuine engagement and may create disparities among students who have different levels of access to service opportunities.

Full question:

Is it illegal for a school to make kids perform service learning, in the form of community service, as a requirement to graduate? This is not a voluntary situation, the school requires students to perform community service in order to graduate.

Category: U.S. Constitution
Subcategory: Thirteenth Amendment
Date: 04/07/2025
State: Colorado

Answer:

There are many articles discussing this issue and we found a few Court Opinions online that address the issue. The two we found hold that it is not a violation of the U.S. Constitution for a school to require community service as a condition of graduation.

The second opinion referenced below was decided in 2015. There could be other Court opinions that address the issue that we did not locate. We also did not locate a U.S. Supreme Court opinion that addressed the issue. If there is one, we did not find it.

There are articles and law journal articles that argue this should be illegal and there are others that argue it should not be declared illegal. However, until there is a definitive decision or enactment by legislatures, it appears to be legal in most circumstances.

References:

http://www.illinoiscourts.gov/opinions/AppellateCourt/2015/4thDistrict/4141111.pdf
https://casetext.com/case/herndon-v-chapel-hill-carrboro-city-board

This content is for informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Legal statutes mentioned reflect the law at the time the content was written and may no longer be current. Always verify the latest version of the law before relying on it.

FAQs

Why shouldn't community service be mandatory?

Mandatory community service can be seen as forced labor, which may violate individual rights. Critics argue it can diminish the value of genuine volunteerism, as students may view it as a chore rather than a meaningful contribution. Additionally, it may disproportionately affect students who have fewer resources or time to fulfill these requirements, potentially leading to stress and inequity.

Can school make you do community service?

Yes, schools can require community service as a condition for graduation, provided it aligns with state laws and educational policies. Courts have generally upheld this practice, viewing it as a legitimate educational requirement. However, students should be informed about the specific requirements and how they can fulfill them.

Is community service a graduation requirement?

What is forced volunteering called?

What are the disadvantages of community service for high school students?

Disadvantages of mandatory community service for high school students include potential stress from balancing service with academic responsibilities, feelings of resentment towards the requirement, and the possibility of unequal access to opportunities. Some students may also feel that the experience lacks personal meaning if it is not voluntary.