US Legal Forms
Legal Resources
Questions & Answers
Civil Actions
What legal recourse do I have to get our antique back?

What legal recourse do I have to get our antique back?

Full question:

My wife's grandmother died and left her a family heirloom (dresser) of which we do not know the value. We took it to a bona fide refinisher and carpenter who has scheduled six separate deliveries with us not once delivering our dresser or calling to inform they were not delivering. We have not paid anything but it has been over two months since the first delivery was scheduled. What legal recourse do I have to either get our antique back or get compensated for the value of the dresser?

Category: Civil Actions
Date: 04/07/2025
State: National

Answer:

You may want to consider filing a civil suit against the refinisher/carpenter for conversion. Conversion is when someone wrongfully uses property of another for their own purposes or alters or destroys it. In an action for conversion, the taking of the property may be lawful, but the retaining of the property is unlawful. To succeed in the action, the plaintiff must prove that he or she demanded the property returned and the defendant refused to do so.

Damages may be recovered for the replacement value of the property as well as for the loss of its use. Conversion is very similar to theft, but is a civil action, not a criminal action. For example, when a mechanic wrongfully refuses to return a car brought in for repairs, it the mechanic may be subject to an action for conversion.

This content is for informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Legal statutes mentioned reflect the law at the time the content was written and may no longer be current. Always verify the latest version of the law before relying on it.

FAQs

Why would you get rid of a family heirloom?

People may choose to get rid of a family heirloom for various reasons. These can include financial need, lack of space, or a desire to declutter. Sometimes, heirs may not feel a personal connection to the item or may prefer to pass it on to someone who appreciates it more. Additionally, if the heirloom is damaged or requires costly repairs, an heir might decide it’s best to sell or donate it.

How are family heirlooms passed down?

Family heirlooms are typically passed down through inheritance, often specified in a will or trust. This process can involve direct gifts to specific heirs or bequeathing items to a family member to distribute later. In some cases, family traditions dictate who receives certain heirlooms, regardless of legal documentation. It's important to communicate intentions clearly to avoid disputes among family members.

Is inheritance during marriage community property?

In most states, inheritance is considered separate property, even if received during marriage. This means that the inheriting spouse retains full ownership of the inherited assets. However, if the inherited property is commingled with community property, it may lose its separate status. It's advisable to keep inherited assets distinct and well-documented to maintain their separate property status.

Are gifts non-marital property?

Yes, gifts received by one spouse are generally considered non-marital property. This means that the recipient spouse retains full ownership of the gift, regardless of when it was received. However, if the gift is used for joint purposes or commingled with marital assets, it could complicate its classification. Keeping clear records of gifts can help maintain their non-marital status.

Are family heirlooms marital property?

Family heirlooms can be classified as marital or separate property depending on the circumstances. If an heirloom is inherited by one spouse, it is usually considered separate property. However, if both spouses use the heirloom or if it is transformed into a joint asset, it may be deemed marital property. Clear documentation and communication about ownership can help clarify the status of family heirlooms.