US Legal Forms
Legal Resources
Questions & Answers
Civil Actions
Can a judge dismiss with prejudice a 2 1/2 yr. old suit because the Plaintiff is disabled?

Can a judge dismiss with prejudice a 2 1/2 yr. old suit because the Plaintiff is disabled?

Q: What is an example of a motion to dismiss with prejudice?

An example of a motion to dismiss with prejudice might occur when a defendant argues that the plaintiff has repeatedly failed to provide necessary evidence or has not followed court rules. The defendant could request the court to dismiss the case permanently, preventing the plaintiff from bringing the same claim in the future.

Q: When can a judge dismiss a case with prejudice?

A judge can dismiss a case with prejudice when it is clear that the plaintiff's claims are legally insufficient or if the plaintiff has previously amended the complaint without success. This type of dismissal is often based on the merits of the case or procedural issues that cannot be corrected.

Q: What would cause a case to be dismissed with prejudice?

A case may be dismissed with prejudice for reasons such as failure to comply with court orders, lack of jurisdiction, or if the claims are deemed frivolous. Additionally, if a plaintiff fails to prosecute their case after being given multiple opportunities, a judge may dismiss it with prejudice.

Q: What is the stipulation of dismissal with prejudice by the plaintiff?

A stipulation of dismissal with prejudice by the plaintiff is a formal agreement between the parties that the case will be dismissed permanently. This means the plaintiff cannot refile the same claim in the future. Such stipulations typically require the consent of both parties and are often filed with the court.

Full question:

Can a judge dismiss with prejudice a 2 1/2 yr. old suit because the Plaintiff is disabled and unable to secure an attorney because she needs to get a loan and Judge granted request to dismiss without prejudice. Plaintiff filed Pro Per knowing her disability would not let her proceed to court (Ephasia, inability to speak due to stroke). Tried to use a person holding power of attorney to act on her behalf for two years of suit. This suit is in Arizona, quiet title action, both parties pro per.

Category: Civil Actions
Date: 04/07/2025
State: Texas

Answer:

I am not sure why you object to the case being dismissed when you are the defendant, unless you have a counterclaim. However, all I can tell you is that, yes, a judge can do that. That power is established by the state consitution (establishing the judiciary) and the rules of court, judicial decisions and statutes. It is unquestioned and unquestionable in the legal profession. The only remedy is to APPEAL. A higher court may agree that the judge acted outside of his discretion and/or contrary to law, and reverse the judge's decision to dismiss.

This content is for informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Legal statutes mentioned reflect the law at the time the content was written and may no longer be current. Always verify the latest version of the law before relying on it.

FAQs

When can a judge dismiss with prejudice?

A judge can dismiss a case with prejudice when they determine that the case cannot be refiled. This often occurs if the plaintiff has failed to comply with court orders, lacks standing, or has engaged in misconduct. Dismissals with prejudice are typically final and prevent the plaintiff from bringing the same claim again.

What is the rule 41 a dismissal?

Rule 41(a) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure allows a plaintiff to voluntarily dismiss a case without prejudice before the defendant serves an answer or a motion for summary judgment. This means the plaintiff can refile the case later. If the defendant has already responded, the plaintiff may need the court's permission to dismiss.