US Legal Forms
Legal Resources
Questions & Answers
Courts
This question is about an employment EEO case in federal court where the orginal pleadings were about discrimination and reta...

This question is about an employment EEO case in federal court where the orginal pleadings were about discrimination and reta...

Full question:

This question is about an employment EEO case in federal court where the orginal pleadings were about discrimination and retaliation. Question Part 1: Do ongoing and later retaliations in a nexus with the case need to be filed with a leave to amend for amended pleadings or are they automatically integrated into the lawsuit? Question: Part 2: Will a response to a motion for summary judgment be sufficient and considered as amended pleadings? See: Ganther v Ingle where a response to MSJ is considered as amended pleadings in the U.S. 5th circuit.In Texas, the law is such that judges always allow a cure for any defect of pleadings, before during, or after trial. However, my question involve federal court. The attorney does not believe that amended pleadings are necessary, since a retaliation claim does not have to be administratively exhausted as a new claim, since it is in nexus with the orginal pleadings or integrated into the law suit.

Category: Courts
Subcategory: Pleadings
Date: 04/07/2025
State: Texas

Answer:

You are asking us to make a specific technical legal judgment that could only be considered legal advice. We cannot give legal advice through this service, only general legal information, and thus cannot give an opinion on your question. I am requesting that our customer service department refund your charge.

You seem to indicate that you have an attorney. If you have retained the services of a local attorney, it would not be unreasonable to trust his/her judgment in these matters (unless you have reason not to). If you have lost confidence in your attorney, consult another local attorney.

We cannot give legal advice. The foregoing is not a substitute for the advice of a local attorney. But we hope the information will be useful.

Sincerely,

USLegal, Inc.

This content is for informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Legal statutes mentioned reflect the law at the time the content was written and may no longer be current. Always verify the latest version of the law before relying on it.

FAQs

What is the process for filing amended pleadings in federal court?

In federal court, if you want to file amended pleadings, you generally need to seek leave from the court. This means you must file a motion to amend and show good cause for the amendment. The court will consider factors such as the timing of the request and potential prejudice to the other party. If the amendment relates to ongoing retaliations connected to the original claim, it may be more straightforward, but formal approval is still typically required.

Can a response to a motion for summary judgment be considered an amended pleading?

In some cases, a response to a motion for summary judgment may be treated as an amended pleading, particularly if it introduces new facts or arguments relevant to the claims. However, this is not guaranteed and can depend on the court's discretion. It's important to consult with an attorney to understand how your specific case may be affected.

Do retaliation claims need to be separately exhausted in federal court?

In federal court, retaliation claims do not typically require separate administrative exhaustion if they are closely related to the original discrimination claims. The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) allows for related claims to be included in the same charge. However, it's advisable to consult an attorney to ensure compliance with all procedural requirements.

What should I do if my attorney disagrees with me about filing amended pleadings?

If you and your attorney disagree about the necessity of filing amended pleadings, it’s important to have an open discussion about your concerns. You can ask your attorney to explain their reasoning and the legal implications. If you still feel uncertain, consider seeking a second opinion from another attorney who specializes in employment law.