US Legal Forms
Legal Resources
Questions & Answers
Contracts
Is the owner liable for unauthorized upgrades by the builder?

Is the owner liable for unauthorized upgrades by the builder?

Full question:

If a contract between a builder and owner states all changes or upgrades must be agreed upon and in writing by both parties, and the builder decided to upgrade the house (by $24,000) without consent, is the owner liable to pay the increase?

Category: Contracts
Subcategory: Breach of Contract
Date: 04/07/2025
State: Tennessee

Answer:

The terms of your contract with the builder will generally define your rights and obligations. Review the contract carefully to understand your position regarding the upgrades. For instance, the contract may allow for emergency work to be done without consent or may define upgrades in a way that excludes those made without agreement.

A breach of contract occurs when one party fails to perform their contractual duties, causing the other party to suffer damages. If the builder upgraded the house without your consent, you may not be liable for the additional cost, as it violates the contract terms. Legal actions for breach of contract typically aim to restore the injured party to their original position, often through monetary damages.

In summary, since the builder made changes without your agreement, you likely are not responsible for the $24,000 increase. However, to resolve any disputes, consider consulting with a legal professional.

This content is for informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Legal statutes mentioned reflect the law at the time the content was written and may no longer be current. Always verify the latest version of the law before relying on it.

FAQs

When a contractor performs work beyond that required by the contract without a formal change order, it is?

When a contractor performs work beyond the contract without a formal change order, it may be considered a breach of contract. The owner is generally not obligated to pay for unauthorized work, as it violates the agreement's terms. However, the contractor may argue for compensation if the work was necessary for safety or compliance. It's essential to review the contract for any provisions regarding unauthorized work.

What are constructive change orders?

Constructive change orders occur when a contractor performs work that is not formally authorized through a change order but is deemed necessary due to the owner's actions or inactions. This can create a situation where the contractor seeks compensation for the additional work, arguing it was implied by the owner's requests or circumstances. It's crucial to document all communications to clarify expectations.

Should a contractor proceed with extra work without a change order?

A contractor should generally avoid proceeding with extra work without a change order, as it can lead to disputes over payment. If the work is necessary, the contractor should seek written approval from the owner to ensure they are compensated. Acting without authorization may expose the contractor to financial risks if the owner refuses to pay for the additional work.

What are the three elements of a construction contract?

The three essential elements of a construction contract are offer, acceptance, and consideration. The offer outlines the work to be done, acceptance confirms that both parties agree to the terms, and consideration refers to the payment or compensation exchanged for the work. Ensuring these elements are clearly defined helps avoid disputes over contractual obligations.