Full question:
I have taken the USMLE step 1 boards four times and failed. On my third attempt, I failed by a point. I feel my last attempt was due to a recent job I had started. My school says that it is mandatory to repeat a semester, but the handbook says it may be required. Also, the acceptance letter states nothing about having to pass this semester. It only specifies I must pass the final shelf exam by 60%. I want to know if it is mandatory for me to retake the semester. If so, must I actually show up and pass every test?
- Category: Education
- Subcategory: Student Rights
- Date:
- State: Pennsylvania
Answer:
In the school setting, the decision about whether you must retake a semester often depends on internal administrative policies. While your school may have guidelines, the determination can be subjective. Courts typically review such cases to ensure that due process rights were respected. This includes whether you received written notice of requirements, were informed of grounds for expulsion or suspension, had the chance to confront evidence against you, and were allowed to have support during proceedings.
It's important to note that students at private universities do not have the same due process rights as those at public schools. Courts usually defer to the decisions made by private institutions, especially regarding internal matters. The standard of review is lenient, requiring that procedures be fundamentally fair and not arbitrary. If your school's policy states requirements in non-mandatory terms, it may be a discretionary matter based on the decision-makers' views. If a rational reason supports the decision, it is likely to be upheld. I recommend checking if there is an appeals or review process available for your situation.
This content is for informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Legal statutes mentioned reflect the law at the time the content was written and may no longer be current. Always verify the latest version of the law before relying on it.